Choosing the right cladding for your house is a crucial decision to ensure your home is protected from the elements. Two popular options are traditional stucco and modern James Hardie fiber cement board, also known as Hardie board.
Stucco has been used as house cladding for centuries, covering some of the oldest properties in the southeastern Pennsylvania area. Meanwhile, James Hardie fiber cement board is one of the newest house cladding materials on the market.
While stucco is a robust product that thrives in the southwest, where moisture is scarce, it’s a different story in Southeastern PA. Here, it’s susceptible to water damage and insect infestations, including termites, that can infiltrate through cracks. Even with a styrofoam backing, modern stucco’s lack of a water barrier can lead to moisture seeping into the wood structure of your home.
James Hardie Fiber Cement
James Hardie fiber cement board, commonly known as Hardie board, is composed of a blend of Portland cement, silica (sand), cellulose fibers, water, and various additives. Portland cement acts as the binder, providing strength and durability, while silica adds hardness and impact resistance. Cellulose fibers, derived from wood pulp, enhance flexibility and reduce the likelihood of cracking. Water is used in the manufacturing process to create a homogeneous slurry, and additional additives improve performance characteristics such as mold and mildew resistance, fire resistance, and UV stability.
These components are combined and cured to create a dense, durable, and versatile building material that is resistant to weather, fire, and pests, making it an excellent choice for exterior cladding in various climates.
James Hardie siding is more water-resistant than stucco, expands and contracts more naturally, and is as cost-effective as stucco. James Hardie’s installation system, too, creates a water barrier that keeps out moisture and insects.
From a visual perspective, James Hardie is available in a wide variety of styles and colors. Stucco looks like, well, stucco. If you like the look, great, but it’s not changeable.
Can You Repair Stucco?
While yes you can repair certain types of stucco damage, it doesn’t resolve the damage that’s already done under the surface. For that reason, stucco repair is not a long-term solution; it’s merely a patch. For a durable product that can withstand the weather conditions of Southeastern PA, a stronger option like James Hardie is the way to go.
Comparing James Hardie to Stucco
While stucco has its historical charm and has served many homes well, it faces significant challenges in the humid climate of Southeastern Pennsylvania. Water damage, insect infestations, and the need for frequent repairs make it a less desirable option for homeowners in this region. James Hardie fiber cement board emerges as a superior alternative, offering excellent water resistance, durability, and aesthetic versatility. By choosing James Hardie, you invest in a cladding solution that not only protects your home but also enhances its curb appeal.
Our Stance on Stucco
Volpe Enterprises, Inc. does not repair or replace stucco due to the water infiltration problems that are commonly found with stucco. While stucco from 100 years ago may still be standing, improperly installed stucco has a short life span and is susceptible to cracking, which allows moisture, rot, and insect infestations to build up behind the stucco. If you are experiencing any kind of stucco problems, we recommend removing the stucco and installing siding.
